HOME

 

SOMALIA ARCHIVE: Sept. 26 - Oct. 1, 2005

Land of the Gun

Warlords are once again on the verge of a major clash. But this showdown pits the interim president against members of his own Cabinet. Amid such animosity, can anything save Somalia?

By Kevin Sites, Thu Sep 29, 12:01 AM ET

MOGADISHU, Somalia - He is a star among Somali warlords.

Osman Hassan Ali Atto is a key character in Ridley Scott's film version of the book "Black Hawk Down." In the first scene Atto (played by George Harris) is captured by American Army Rangers. Understandably, he didn't care much for the movie.

"Military propaganda," he tells me during an interview at his Mogadishu compound, which is strewn with vehicle parts and heavy machinery.

His role in the movie does, however, illustrate the man's Gumby-like flexibility, shifting between roles that would leave most crying whiplash.

Atto's an operator at the most fundamental level. He's able to broker deals between competing interests or even with those he sometimes directly opposes -- as long they pay on time.

He's been a real estate speculator, an oilman, a construction contractor and a militia leader. Now he's the minister of public works in Somalia's interim government -- a government that he and other cabinet members are now threatening to go to war against.

"One single bullet," Atto says solemnly, "can ignite the old animosities, and at that point the fighting could start at any time."

Atto points the finger at Somalia's interim president, Abdullahi Yusuf Ahmed, whom he says has ambitions beyond the 2004 charter signed in Kenya that created the interim government. Atto says Yusuf is too closely aligned with longtime Somali nemesis Ethiopia.

And there are other major disputes. Among them, the decision by Yusuf not to set up the new government in Mogadishu, which he says still lacks basic security. He instead chose to operate out of Jowhar, a town closer to his own power base.

Like trash in the streets, rumors swirl in Mogadishu. Atto echoes some of them: that Yusuf has amassed a militia of 3,000 men and 100 technicals (pickups mounted with machine guns) ready to take the city and members of his mutinous cabinet, by force.

But a spokesman for the interim government, Abdirahman Yusuf Meygag, says the rumors are completely false.

"This is out of Atto's imagination," Meygag said in a recent Reuters wire report. "The government remains deeply focused and committed on seeking peaceful means to resolving disputes."

But Atto says he's not convinced.

"We are preparing ourselves to resist and I believe we have enough arms to defend ourselves," he says. "If Mr. Yusuf wants to renew the fighting between Somalis, he's quite welcome, but if he behaves like a decent individual -- he is president of this country -- there is room for him. But it's up to him to decide whichever way he wants."

The legacy of inter-clan fighting here has been as consistent as the waves pounding the Somali shoreline. Warlords like Mohammed Farrah Aidid, as well as both Yusuf and Atto, helped to overthrow Somali dictator Siad Barre in 1991.

Unable to agree on who would replace him, the warlords started fighting among themselves, plunging the nation into 14 years of chaos during which there has been no central government.

This anarchy, combined with bouts of famine and disease, has led to the deaths of almost one million people.

Habibo Hassan fled her home in southern Mogadishu during the fighting in 1993 and never went back. She's been living in a refugee camp with her six children since.

"Everything was destroyed," she says. "We had nothing to go back to."

Rumors of new clashes make her concerned again for the safety of her children.

Abdi Hashi with gun

Thirty-year-old Abdi Hashi sells Chinese-made electronics from a wooden stall in the Bakhaara Market. He says the potential for violence has hurt his business. He's lucky, he says, if he sells a few items a day -- bringing in the equivalent of about four U.S. dollars.

"It's not enough to take care of my three kids," he says. "If one of them gets sick and I have to buy medicine, then we go without a meal."

Abdi pulls out a 9 mm pistol from a bag at his feet.

"But if the fighting starts, I'll be ready," he says with confidence, proud to have at least a little control in his life.

"Which side will you fight on?" I ask.

"Neither," he says. "This is just for protection -- for me and my family."

If the fighting does begin again, however, opposing sides seem to agree Somalia's misery index could rise to a whole new level.

Turf battles between warlords are already a daily occurrence, with fights over income-generating commodities like roadblocks, guns, and most importantly, the supply of khat (the plant many Somali men chew for its stimulant qualities). With renewed fighting, turf battles could get even fiercer.

Ali Muhammed, deputy director of the International Red Cross-funded Medina Hospital in Mogadishu, shows me the triage board in the emergency room. Under the heading "weapons related injuries" there are at least five or six entries every day.

"When there are militia clashes," he says, "those numbers will go up to between 15 and 25 a day. It's all we can do to keep up with them."

As he finishes the sentence, orderlies push in a gurney with a blanket-covered body with only a hand exposed.

"One of the gunshot victims from last night," Ali tells me.

In the recovery ward, 24-year-old Abdul Khadir has a tube sticking out of the right side of his chest. The night before, he tells me, he was watching a football match on television at a local cafe when three men from a nearby village drove up and sprayed the crowd with gunfire. Five people were killed. He was the only survivor.

"This would not have happened if we had a government, some kind of security," he says.

With Somalia on the brink of fighting once again, people here are beginning to question whether the warlords and political leaders even want stability because they seem to profit so much from the chaos.

Atto insists he wants peace, despite beating the drums for war. He says only international intervention can stave off the violence.

"Somalia must be given a chance," he says. "Instead of letting us sink in the mud, the international community must assist Somalia."

The United States says it is the largest bilateral donor to the "Somali people," providing $30 million annually.

According to the State Department, the U.S. does not provide direct assistance to the transitional government because "it has not yet established itself as a functioning government inside Somalia."

On the diplomatic front,

United Nations Special Envoy in Somalia Francois Fall has been shuttling back and forth between the factions but says the parties won't meet for face-to-face discussions.

"We are facing one of the most difficult conflicts in Africa," he said in a release after a recent trip.

Despite being a central player in the latest crisis, Atto begins to sound more conciliatory during our interview.

Perhaps it's a demonstration of that deal-making flexibility that has profited him so well in the past. Atto is a man whose life is summed up by the current juxtaposition of artillery shells next to a construction backhoe.

"I think there is hope," he says, "if the international community and Somalis decide they want to stop the fighting. If we establish a government with security, the gunmen will disappear in a minute."

Optimistic words from a man whose own gunmen nearby adjust the sights of an anti-aircraft gun mounted on a Toyota land cruiser.

--Corrected Sept 29, 2005, to clarify that George Harris played Atto in the movie "Black Hawk Down."

http://hotzone.yahoo.com/b/hotzone/blogs1054

RECOMMEND THIS STORY

Recommend It:

Average (Not Rated)

0.0 stars
Hot Zone Watch List
  • Algeria
  • Angola
  • Burundi
  • Chad
  • Ivory Coast
  • Korean Peninsula
  • Liberia
  • Nigeria
  • Peru
  • The Philippines
  • Thailand
  • Uzbekistan
  • Zimbabwe

Comments

Join the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

1
my answer is as long as humans are possessed with greed and power, nothing can improve.
Posted by luv_ll_play on Thu, Sep 29, 2005 3:41 AM ET
2
I spent some time in Somalia as a medic with 10th Mountain during Operation Restore Hope. Because of the ignorance, greed and absolute disregard for human life, there is no hope for this country. Let them rot...
Posted by oygaval on Thu, Sep 29, 2005 4:01 AM ET
3
The Somali's were handed their chance to rid themselves of the Warlords and to come into the international fold with America's bold intervention there. The Somali's and only the Somali's are responsible for the failure of that mission and their current state of affairs. If it wasn't for the ties to Al Queda I would say let the African Union and UN handle that mess.
Posted by tknight_1204 on Thu, Sep 29, 2005 5:24 AM ET
4
i see callous remarks being posted in the comments. people who think in an isolationist manner would rue later when its going to affect them later, in today's complexly interconnected world. its time that everyone comes together with the 'best intentions' and deliver the promises made to normalise the situation in Somalia Rajdeep
Posted by pakanati22 on Thu, Sep 29, 2005 6:22 AM ET
5
An interesting thought came to mind while reading this article. I see many folks preach the virtues of anarchy. Those who believe the world would be a better place under anarchy should spend some time in Somalia, the only example of true anarchy that I know of. A short time spent there should convince anyone that anarchy is a naive idea.
Posted by sstidman on Thu, Sep 29, 2005 6:55 AM ET
6
im a medic in the army and i say that we should stay out of Somalia. We tried once, but Somalia isnt Iraq. While theres hope in Iraq, as little as it may seem, there is no hope for Somalia. I think the people of Somalia like the way things are. If they didnt, there would be no movie called "Black Hawk Down".
Posted by danielhill3642 on Thu, Sep 29, 2005 7:17 AM ET
7
I think Somalia is not a "real" country. It was formed from former colonies, without regard of they own believes. Perhaps, it is time to let them choose they own way - for better or worse. No international donations, neither US or UN, will help. Perhaps it will be easier to start with a different approach: Muslim africans should start helping their brothers, an get a halt in fighting.
Posted by ramirorivero on Thu, Sep 29, 2005 7:30 AM ET
8
It's amazing to read the contrasting opinions whether the US should or should not intervene in these matters. Either way the US loses. If we intervene then we are accused of interfering in a nation's affairs ostensibly for our own evil purposes. If we leave them to their own devices then we are callous and evil for allowing people to die. Reporters go into these areas and stir up people to call for action and then way for the story to unfold and shred anything that is done to help. Its really about reporters self-aggrandizement and just plain making a name for themselves getting the "scoop". In this case, Somali's had their chance. In particular, the people and clans of Mogadishu made a choice. They voted with their actions and now are reaping their fruits. The US went into Iraq for security and freedom, supposedly, and not oil of course, and is now bogged down in the beginnings of a civil war between sunnis and @#$% es. The US always loses when we help others. Maybe it is time for a little isolationism. Let the world go to devil for a year. Then let's see how they feel on their own then. Will people die. Yes, and its time that they look to their own for why and not blame everyone else for their own troubles.
Posted by jorgef176 on Thu, Sep 29, 2005 8:14 AM ET
9
Oygaval, I simply do not have any answer, but I can assure you that as long as there is but one man, woman or child who believes in tomorrow, there will be hope. Even for Somalia. Somewhere there is at least one Somalian that believes.
Posted by jamic07 on Thu, Sep 29, 2005 8:57 AM ET
10
Nothing or no one should the scums of the earth. They themselves have created this situation that they are currently in. Even when the US and the rest of the world extended its hands to help they have rejected it for their short term gains and endless greed! A nation that cant help itself should not be HELPED!!! So, I would urge the rest of the world to let them suffer and destroy themselves, THERE IS NO POINT HELPING THE FOOLS!!! - Ryan Dhaka, Bangladesh
Posted by ryanilahi on Thu, Sep 29, 2005 9:04 AM ET

ALSO ON YAHOO!

One Man. One Year. A World of Conflict.

Kevin's Flickr Photo Journal

Other Trip Posts

Add to My Yahoo!/RSS

  • Add Hot Zone headlines to My Yahoo!

    Add to My Yahoo! xml
» All News RSS Feeds
share this page
Alerts BellAdd an Alert - Receive the latest Hot Zone dispatches by email, instant message or mobile phone.

Learn More

» Web Search: Somalia

HOW TO HELP

in memoriam

The Kevin Sites in the Hot Zone team dedicates this site to Marla Ruzicka, a fearless voice of compassion, who was killed in Iraq on April 16, 2005, while trying to lessen the suffering of others. For more information, see Civic Worldwide.