HOME

 

SPECIAL FEATURESNov. 2006 - Sept. 2007

After the Shooting

Before Virginia Tech, before Columbine, there was Paducah, Ky. A 1997 school shooting there left Missy Jenkins Smith paralyzed, but not without hope. She has a husband, a baby on the way and a message on how to stop the violence.

By Kevin Sites, Fri Apr 20, 5:00 AM ET

MURRAY, Ky. — The massacre at Virginia Tech seemed more like a memory than news to Missy Jenkins Smith.

"When something like that happens, it's almost like re-living it again," she says from the kitchen of her house in Murray, Ky.

It should. The details of the Virginia Tech tragedy are strikingly similar to the Dec. 1, 1997, school shooting at Heath High School in Paducah, Ky., that turned Jenkins Smith from a member of the marching band into a T4 paraplegic — paralyzed from the chest down.

Every morning she would meet in the school lobby with 30 to 40 other students to say a prayer before the start of the day. That morning, freshman Michael Carneal, a 14-year-old outcast often bullied because of his small frame and clownish behavior, brought a loaded .22 handgun to school.

Video

Missy Jenkins Smith discusses how her life has changed since being paralyzed in a 1997 school shooting » View

"After we said 'Amen,' he pulled the .22 out of his backpack and started shooting at us," she says. "And the very first thing I saw was someone get shot in the head."

Like student accounts from Virginia Tech, Jenkins Smith says she thought the violence wasn't real — that it was just an elaborate prank.

But then a bullet entered her left shoulder, pierced her lung and severed her spinal cord. She fell to the ground, but still didn't realize she had been shot until her twin sister, who protected Missy's body with her own, told her what had happened.

She had not seen the shooter, but her sister had. The name Michael Carneal shocked her almost as much as her wounds. He had been a friend.

"Whenever there was a class trip, I always wanted to get on the same bus as him because I knew he would make the ride fun," like when he made a cape out of a "Twister" game board, she recalls.

But others were laughing at Carneal, not with him — something he shrugged off on the outside, she says. But on the inside, he seethed.

Carneal fired eight rounds into the group of praying students, but when he saw he had hit some of his friends, he put down his gun and surrendered to the principal.

When the shooting stopped, he had hit eight students, killing three and wounding five.

He received three consecutive life sentences. Soon after the shooting he wrote to Jenkins Smith to apologize, but she wasn't ready to deal with him yet.

He even called her family home. When her father answered, Jenkins Smith recalls, Carneal just said, "I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I'm sorry," until her father hung up the phone.

In the letters he wrote, Jenkins Smith says, Carneal talked about his problems, including feelings of paranoia — again, similar to the persecution complex expressed by the Virginia Tech shooter, Seung-Hui Cho.

Jenkins Smith says now, 10 years later, she's ready to speak with Carneal and ask him questions that have bothered her for a decade.

Missy Jenkins Smith, her husband Josh
and an ultrasound image of their child

She would like to know what he was thinking when he brought the gun to school. "What was going through your mind when you did this?"

She says Carneal's answers would help her in the work that she's taken up since the shooting: speaking to school students about preventing the kind of violence that changed her life. It has become her purpose in life, she says.

"I need to warn people about what I've learned from the school shooting," she says. "About the importance of treating others the way you would want to be treated."

She says bullying and treating other students with disrespect can push social misfits on the edge to murder. She says it's also critical to read the warning signs; students that do resort to violence will usually give off indications of what they're about to do.

"I always try to tell people about the importance of speaking up when they see these signs," she says. "I'm a pretty good visual about what violence can do."

Despite what was taken from her, Jenkins Smith didn't surrender to her circumstances. She went to college and earned a degree in social work. Now, fittingly, she has a full time job working with emotionally disturbed students.

She also got married last year to a man she met in college, physical education teacher Josh Smith.

But perhaps the most appropriate and symbolic representation of her sense of hope is the fact that she is now four months pregnant.

"We weren't sure it would happen," says Josh Smith, tossing a stuffed animal around with their dog Charlie in their living room. "But obviously everything works," he says with a smile.

"Just because I'm in a wheelchair and paralyzed," says Jenkins Smith, "doesn't mean I can't do things anyone else can do."

She says that she will teach her child about the dangers of life; it indeed can be a violent world. She is a perfect example. But she'll also teach that showing a little respect and kindness could be just what it takes to disarm an angry soul.

http://hotzone.yahoo.com/b/hotzone/blogs29856

RECOMMEND THIS STORY

Recommend It:

Average (Not Rated)

0.0 stars
Hot Zone Watch List
  • Algeria
  • Angola
  • Burundi
  • Chad
  • Ivory Coast
  • Korean Peninsula
  • Liberia
  • Nigeria
  • Peru
  • The Philippines
  • Thailand
  • Uzbekistan
  • Zimbabwe

Comments

Join the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

1
Hopefully this woman's life (and the life within her:) can be a sign of strength and inspiration for those affected by the needless tragedies in the world. It can take much hard work and perserverance to find good where there only seems to be evil. Missy Jenkins Smith shows that facing the pain and grief head on can be done and is worth it. Best of luck to her, her husband and their growing family. Thank you for shining a light on this incredibly inspiring woman and her journey!
Posted by ouijuju on Fri, Apr 20, 2007 1:09 AM ET
2
I am teary- eyed by your story, I am so touched. I really know what she is talking about. Sometimes people just seem to be so mean that it delights them that some other people are deeply hurt. It also inflict internal emotional disturbance especially when they don't have no one to turn to. Parents are too busy working that they fail to teach good values. Also in this society there are a number of people who just don't care enough that they focused on people's flaw to make it as a laughing stock especially in speaking English. I thank you for sharing your story. Before in school, I always like to befriend less liked people because I consider it as a challenge to break a barrier with the person and only me can understand his feelings. People may not understand him but I do and felt I have done something good for the person.
Posted by cnoribeth on Fri, Apr 20, 2007 6:57 AM ET
3
This is the only sensible piece I have read so far on the tragedy. People these days especially kids are very judgmental and border on cruelty in their behaviour. Lot of bullied children commit suicides, some are driven to this. A little kindness, understanding and inclusiveness goes a long way.
Posted by shrotrisare on Fri, Apr 20, 2007 9:56 AM ET
4
Thank you as always Kevin for bringing us the human story. You truly do embody what a journalist should really be. I hope you and your team are planning another HotZone special. I really looked forward to reading your columns every day because they brought to light and understanding what real people in these "far-off" conflicts are going through. Thank you for this story.
Posted by lauren_taggart1 on Fri, Apr 20, 2007 10:24 AM ET
5
I found that story very eye opening. Kindness does to alot. But my theory is if we made the bullets cost in thousands maybe it would be harder to get them and than parents wouldn't buy to many and than our children couldn't get to them. I still believe we should bare arms I just wish we could find a solution if not maybe we can start with kindness
Posted by monae63 on Fri, Apr 20, 2007 10:57 AM ET
6
I totally agree with this story, as I am from different country I can say it really hurt when people instead of co-operating you make fun of you, for your language and avoid you. I am totally disagree with the gunman action, that is not the way to solve the problem, but it could be avoided by giving respect to the people who are different. Instead of criticising them, make them feel comfortable,put your self in the same situation and try to act the same way you want others to act with you.
Posted by rosymushtak2000 on Fri, Apr 20, 2007 11:15 AM ET
7
Must everyone be so cruel? When I first read these comments, there was one on here that shouldn't have been here. I am glad to see that it's gone. But, those are the exact reasons why people do what they do. I believe that everyone should mind their own business, quit picking and prodding to make yourself better, and smile. Because ultimately, innocent people are losing their lives for things they have never done. Think about it....next time, it could be you. I don't think violence will end until we put an end to our selfish behaviors.
Posted by armedsunshine on Fri, Apr 20, 2007 2:55 PM ET
8
I think that alot of these problems stem from a lack of caring and family focused parents. I was picked on everyday in school from 4th grade thru my senior year. But did I go out an get a gun and shot up my school, no I found a close friend and I had a mother that spent time with me and we had great times. We also had alot of tough times but there are other solutions to the worst of times. I think if more parents were involved with their childrens lives and not so wrapped up in themselves we would have less of these terrible crimes happening in our schools. Kindness and understanding is what can really help out alot these days.
Posted by runt0432 on Fri, Apr 20, 2007 4:52 PM ET
9
What a wonderful story of someone who has been there and didn't retaliate. Some people not only young people make themselves feel better by belittling others. Sit in the lounge of a nursing home and you can find the same kind of one trying to make others feel bad, just to make themselves look big in the eyes of others. Caro433
Posted by hughes1633@sbcglobal.net on Fri, Apr 20, 2007 5:14 PM ET
10
You know they are preaching day in and day out about gun control but that will be like out-lawing drinking. It didn't work then and neither will this. Guns don't kill people, people kill people. People are using guns as scapegoats for bad parenting. No discipline, no control, just letting them do what they want to and its getting worse. Parents need to get involved with their kids. Find out what is going on and ask questions. Don't try to be a friend, be a parent.
Posted by adarrah84 on Fri, Apr 20, 2007 5:58 PM ET

ALSO ON YAHOO!

One Man. One Year. A World of Conflict.

Kevin's Flickr Photo Journal

Other Trip Posts

Add to My Yahoo!/RSS

  • Add Hot Zone headlines to My Yahoo!

    Add to My Yahoo! xml
» All News RSS Feeds
share this page
Alerts BellAdd an Alert - Receive the latest Hot Zone dispatches by email, instant message or mobile phone.

in memoriam

The Kevin Sites in the Hot Zone team dedicates this site to Marla Ruzicka, a fearless voice of compassion, who was killed in Iraq on April 16, 2005, while trying to lessen the suffering of others. For more information, see Civic Worldwide.