HOME

 

HAITI ARCHIVE: April 30 - May 14, 2006

Bottom of the Heap

For four mothers in Cite Soleil, digging through garbage is the ultimate in trickle down economics.

By Kevin Sites, Wed May 10, 6:37 PM ET

PORT-AU-PRINCE, Haiti - This is one example of how wealth is redistributed in Haiti.

It rains.

The rains wash the garbage of the upper class neighborhood of Petionville down to the slums of Cite Soleil.

There is already too much garbage in Cite Soleil. Garbage that doesn't disappear.

Garbage, like despair, that piles higher and higher.

Garbage that breeds disease... and contempt.

White fields of plastic, cups, cardboard. A harvest of consumption's remnants.

There is no beauty in it. None at all.

But to some there is value.

Value for those so far down the food chain that even waste offers rewards, if you're willing to sift through it.

Photos

Rummaging for an income » View

Benita Claremont, Nicole Emile, Nadine Paul and Berlange Nicholas are willing to sift. They are mothers — mothers whose children have to be fed, educated, cared for. Yes, they're willing to sift. To sift for hours every time it rains. They use pitchforks and their hands.

Others in Cite Soleil, those a bit better off, ridicule them.

"It's very difficult but we don't have a choice," Nadine says. "It would be nice if we could start a business."

Nadine has four children and is 30 years old.

"The worst is the humiliation from the other people who live here," says Nadine. "They call us 'cocoarats' — little bugs that crawl in the garbage."

Nadine is a survivor — not in a figurative sense — literally. While she was plucking garbage one day, in the midst of Cite Soleil's frequent violence, a stray bullet found her neck.

She shows me the scar. It looks like a puzzle piece. The bullet traveled a crooked path around her jaw line before making its exit.

In a life defined by daily Jobian-sized trials there is no missing the point of this injury's gross insult. 

The mothers work the garbage field as if it were a field of crops. They rake and stoop and bend. It is backbreaking work done in the searing heat of the Haitian sun. It smells of rot — fetid, pungent, inescapable.

It's not an easy place to be when the rewards of your labors are some pieces of charcoal, bottles and wire — and what you get for cashing them in is the equivalent of a buck and a half for a day's work.

"It's not enough," Benita says. She has six children and won't divulge her age. "But we don't have a choice."

Benita

Benita and Nicole are sisters. Both have acquired a sort of blankness behind the eyes. Benita's is dialed all the way up. In Nicole's there is still a hint of sadness. She is 25 and already a mother of four. Life has not been gentle.

"After the rains our house was flooding so we had to leave," says Nicole. "When we came back, we had nothing. It was washed away."

For 20-year-old Berlange it is all about her children — trying to pay for school so they might have a chance to escape this poverty.

"We can't even afford education," she says, "school fees are too high" ... especially when their husbands (with the exception of Benita's, who is dead), like most men in Cite Soleil, are unemployed, with few prospects for work.

"We have experienced so many bad things we can't even dream," Benita says, "We can only hope things will get better."

But today, for these four mothers, what has flowed down from Petionville looks like anything and everything but hope.

http://hotzone.yahoo.com/b/hotzone/blogs4257

RECOMMEND THIS STORY

Recommend It:

Average (Not Rated)

0.0 stars
Hot Zone Watch List
  • Algeria
  • Angola
  • Burundi
  • Chad
  • Ivory Coast
  • Korean Peninsula
  • Liberia
  • Nigeria
  • Peru
  • The Philippines
  • Thailand
  • Uzbekistan
  • Zimbabwe

Comments

Join the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

1
poor people, what can they do when they have no education and therefore know no means of getting out of this mess. It's is the fault of their government which consists of so-called educated people.They have been voted into where they are now, they have been given the trust of those people and they should help them.
Posted by flower_sun_miracle on Wed, May 10, 2006 7:12 PM ET
2
Our first child, Micah, who came to live with us when we started House of Compassion, is from Cite Soleil. He is now 7, after living with us for 5 years, he has learning disability because of not finding any nutrition his first 2 years of life. This is a terrible place and we are doing what we can to help. In the US there are so many social programs for people to turn to for help, in Haiti there is none. The only place they can turn to is international aid organization to help them find some relief. We have people knocking on our door everyday seeking help, it is very sad. Pray for Haiti. It needs Jesus. www.missionsinhaiti.com
Posted by aliciamclloyd on Wed, May 10, 2006 7:27 PM ET
3
"ultimate in trickle down economics", try no economics. Liberals love to use this term to show their disgust for capitalism. It has no relevance in Haiti's situation but in America it is a part of life and works good. You have to have people at all economic levels for the system to work (including the motivator to improve ones own economic status). The other option is the classless communist/socialist utopia structure like in use in Europe that has been proven time and time again to not work.
Posted by jamzlock on Wed, May 10, 2006 7:51 PM ET
4
Kevin here you go again trying to put out negative Propaganda about the black Israelites in Haiti. Guess what you two legged dog the Israelites are not in Israel. So where are they? They are in Haiti the west Indies Brazil the U.S. etc. Moses all the Prophets were black Moses a black man married a cu@#$% e(a black woman) the whole bible talk about blacks only. So where is you beast peoples religion in the fraudulent NewTestament. With your soul damning J-Esus i.e, Essus druid god Christos i.e, Khrishna religion. You beast people invented the new Testament a book that has no prophecy accept revelation which really is an Old Testament book you stole from the Black Israelites book. You even invented your fake Messiah J-Esus who violated every one of Yahweh's commandments and knew nothing of Yahweh's will. It's not actually dirt they(whitey) says dirt for sensationalism.I am not taking for haitians either because i see how they are towards there own black haitians that go there on vacation. Haitian blacks got American blacks and all other blacks beat whites know they have black americans under control with crack, jamaicans are under control with ganja. Whites know however they mess with haitians we'll zombify them. They are still reeling from how we massacred and butchered them. What we have to remember here is what happened in the garden of Eve it is a story about sex . Lucifer lured Eve and had sex with her creating the white race. Adam was black he created Yahweh's children with Eve the black adamic man. Dirt is black.Black's are the true nation of Israel, Yahweh's children.Isreal is in Northeast Africa. Whites are lucifer's descendants through Eve. the blacks in Haiti and elswhere are the true Israelites. Whites are lucifer's children. Cain who is whites ancestor married a monkey. There was a mark put on cain by Yahweh cain was turned white. Everytime the Black superhuman creator Yahweh cursed someone in the Bible he turned them white. Anyway , back to our story Cain married a monkey the monkey had children creating whites you see today. Do an internet search of humans with tails and you only see whites. Monkeys have thin lips and flat bottoms so do whites and whites have the same animal hair. Have you ever heard of the wolf boys of Mexico if you really want to know what white people look like do an internet search of them and you see true white people in all there bestiality and hair deformalities
Posted by gary10p on Wed, May 10, 2006 8:17 PM ET
5
gary10p is an idiot, shutup stupid...
Posted by reskiles on Wed, May 10, 2006 8:34 PM ET
6
Kevin, may I ask, while you were interviewing them and photographing them, did you give them a few bucks each to help them buy some little luxuries in life?
Posted by jjtan_my on Wed, May 10, 2006 8:49 PM ET
7
gary10p....that rant was absolutely hilarious! I needed a good laugh after that depressing article. If there is a website with your theories, please post the address. I would love to read about that stuff. Absolutely hilarious!!!
Posted by gannawdm on Wed, May 10, 2006 8:54 PM ET
8
gary10p....that rant was absolutely hilarious! I needed a good laugh after that depressing article. If there is a website with your theories, please post the address. I would love to read about that stuff. Absolutely hilarious!!!
Posted by gannawdm on Wed, May 10, 2006 8:54 PM ET
9
It is sad that the USA is trying to spread democracy in a region that wants no part of it. They hate the Cuban government & call it godless communism. Yet Haiti has always wanted to be & vehemently embrace democracy & no one will help them develop a true democracy in the region that holds the democratic banner so high. I sometimes wonder....is the reason for lack of assistance for Haiti because the inhabitants are black. Why would a government try & plant their precious democracy in a place that doesn't want it for a people who will ultimately rip it to shreds and let the people if Haiti starve in their own backyard? Haiti was a rebel colony from birth. But in the modern world today what is the problem with the Haitian nation. America should be ashamed of itself. Spouting about spreading democracy while practicing outright racism.....Again I ask, why is it so important to make the Arab nations democratic while ignoring the screams of those who embrace it in their own hemisphere?
Posted by mainman2167 on Wed, May 10, 2006 8:58 PM ET
10
Haiti needs family planning more than religion. Why are poor women having three, four, five, six, seven children, when they can least afford it? Where are the condoms? Curse the Catholic Church! And in the case of countries like Haiti, there will be no progress until the population is controlled. Eugenics, perhaps? Jimt.
Posted by ji5997211 on Wed, May 10, 2006 9:01 PM ET

ALSO ON YAHOO!

One Man. One Year. A World of Conflict.

Kevin's Flickr Photo Journal

Other Trip Posts

Add to My Yahoo!/RSS

  • Add Hot Zone headlines to My Yahoo!

    Add to My Yahoo! xml
» All News RSS Feeds
share this page
Alerts BellAdd an Alert - Receive the latest Hot Zone dispatches by email, instant message or mobile phone.

Learn More

» Web Search: Haiti

HOW TO HELP

  • Doctors Without Borders: Haiti - provides emergency medical care, rehabilitation care, and public health services.
  • Global Giving: Haiti - sponsors a series of projects in areas such as microcredit, public health, and literac.
  • The Lambi Project - channels resources to community-based organizations that promote social and economic empowerment.
  • Save the Children: Haiti -supports initiatives in education, health, nutrition and food security to improve the well-being of poor children and their families.
  • American Red Cross: Haiti - provides emergency relief services, and support an AIDS awareness campaign in the country.
  • Human Rights Watch: Haiti - bulletins and in-depth reports on the human rights situation in the country.

in memoriam

The Kevin Sites in the Hot Zone team dedicates this site to Marla Ruzicka, a fearless voice of compassion, who was killed in Iraq on April 16, 2005, while trying to lessen the suffering of others. For more information, see Civic Worldwide.