HOME

 

KASHMIR ARCHIVE: May 29 - June 6, 2006

Boat People

Unable to afford homes on land, the poorest of Kashmir’s poor live on open fishing boats, where life is always unsteady.

By Kevin Sites, Tue Jun 6, 2:07 AM ET

SRINAGAR, India-controlled

Kashmir - The children are hard to control, says Mahooda, when you live on a boat.

When home is only 20 feet long and three and a half feet wide, it's understandable that her three girls — Rosie, nine, Daisy, 8, and four-year-old Fancy, — get a little hyperactive when the boats are docked and they can actually play on dry land.

Her son Maqbool isn't a problem yet, since he's only two and spends most of the time in her arms.

"Of course we'd like to live on land," says Mahooda, "but we're poor people. We can't afford to."

Mahooda, along with her husband, children and in-laws, have lived on four small boats, called shikaras, for the last ten years.

Video

Living on the water» View

Her husband and father-in-law take two of them out to fish each day while she, her mother-in-law Fazi, and the children spend the day in the other two, close to shore.

Fazi says she might as well be in a boat. She's already lost much of the mobility in her arms and legs for reasons she can't understand, and the cost makes seeing a doctor out of the question.

At Dal Lake, where many tourists spend their holidays living on board one of the hundreds of large houseboats along the lake, it is ironic that Mahooda and her family have to live on boats that are really no more than large canoes. There are no official estimates of how many people have been forced by poverty to live on their shikaras, but Fazi estimates that there are at least a few thousand scattered around Dal Lake.

The family earns only about five dollars a day, selling the fish the men catch. Money is so tight that almost everything they catch has to be sold. In the stern of boat, a few tiny fish that look like lake bass, long dead, are piled in a plastic bowl. They begin attracting flies when the breeze drops.

The family eats its catch only a few times a week, instead subsisting on rice and vegetables that Mahooda cooks in aluminum pots over a wood fire on shore.

The children have sweet and mischievous faces and are well versed in their responsibilities. They are soft-spoken but relentless in asking for money, forgetting about it only when we begin a project of making airplanes from paper ripped from my notepad.

"I constantly worry about them," Mahooda says. "Can you imagine four small children in this environment? You have to watch them constantly."

Photos

The residents of Dal Lake» View

She says they've fallen into the water by accident many times. She fears they could drown. Mahooda points at Fancy's foot, which is bandaged.

"She cut it when she fell against the side of the boat a few days ago."

The children are not in school, because Mahooda says that is another cost the family just can't bear. And without an education, she worries that they could be condemned to this lifestyle into adulthood.

It's a beautiful evening, with a soft breeze and temperatures dropping to a more comfortable level after a hot day. With the magic light of dusk painting everything golden, the setting seems ideal — and it would be if the family had a place to go after this "afternoon outing" was over. But for Mahooda and her family, it's never over, especially when the warmth of summer days turns into chilly fall and then to unforgiving winter, when the lake sometimes ices over.

They pack all of their meager possessions on the boats — pots and pans, extra clothes, a few bedrolls. While the boats have wood frames that can be covered and turned into roofs, they don't do much to keep out the rain and cold when the weather turns bad.

Even basic hygiene is a complicated maneuver on the shikaras. To wash themselves, Mahooda says, they paddle the boats early in the morning to the center of the lake, where there is less  emerald green hyacinth algae covering the water.

And nighttime on the boats can become a nightmare for the family.

"It's almost impossible to sleep," Fazi says, "because we're all on top of each other."

Despite all of their difficulties, Mahooda seems to be able to smile and laugh at her childrens' shenanigans. But it's obvious the constant exposure to elements has stripped the smoothness of her youth.

It's a harsh life, she concedes, especially during the rain and snow of the winter months. She looks at her children and then off into the distance, still holding Maqbool while she stands steady in the hull of her home.

"I want to hope for something better," she says, "but what can you change when you make only 250 rupees [$5] a day? Every day we live like this is the worst day."

http://hotzone.yahoo.com/b/hotzone/blogs5224

RECOMMEND THIS STORY

Recommend It:

Average (Not Rated)

0.0 stars
Hot Zone Watch List
  • Algeria
  • Angola
  • Burundi
  • Chad
  • Ivory Coast
  • Korean Peninsula
  • Liberia
  • Nigeria
  • Peru
  • The Philippines
  • Thailand
  • Uzbekistan
  • Zimbabwe

Comments

Join the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

1
wow-amazing people are forced to live like this in this day and age.
Posted by bmeadows@prodigy.net on Mon, Jun 5, 2006 11:52 PM ET
2
Assalamualaikum, Thanks alot for reporting this Kevin Sites. I really appreciate the independent coverage you guys are doing on issues which mainstream media considers unimportant. I hope that you guys inspire a new generation of reporters who are sincere in informing the world about all that goes on in it. Thank You and God Bless your efforts.
Posted by cell_junction on Tue, Jun 6, 2006 12:09 AM ET
3
Hello, I have read the last few articles and the comments on them. Those comments sounded very anti-India. Well, I wonder whether the peole posting them know anything about India? I am a Muslim, born and brought up in India. Let me first confess that though I am a Muslim, I am a very proud Indian. Though, my religion is in the minority, I have never felt left out from the society. Two of my best friends are Hindus and one is a Christian. Never ever I felt that I was not a part of this country or its culture. We have equal rights in the country. We are allowed to vote and can choose our leaders. My elder brother fought in the Kargil war shoulder to shoulder with our Hindu brothers against Pakistan. And, my community is proud of him. Why? Because, this is our motherland. So what, we are not the majority religion? Where will we go if we leave this beautiful country??? Will Pakistan accept us ????? They have labled all the Muslims who migrated to Pakistan as Muhajirs. The Muhajirs were never able to assimilite in Pakistan. They were and will always be discriminated. In India, which is a secular country, you are a free will. The soicitey at large always accepts you. There are plenty of examples ... many Bollywood star (Amir Khan, Shah Rukh Khan, Salman Khan, Saif Ali Khan, Fardeen Khan, Diya Mirza, Katrina Kaif, A.R. Rehman, Dilip Kumar, Madhubala, etc) are Muslims. Indians have looked at their talent and many people worship these actors, inspite of them being Muslims. Pakistani artists such as Adnam Sami, Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan, etc., have made it bigger in India than in Pakistan. Pakistan does not even allow Indian artists to perform in Pakistan. Why? Pick up any field, Muslims have done as well as any other Indian citizen. In Cricket, the most popular sport, Irfan Khan, Mohammed Kaif, Zaheer Khan, Wasim Zafer, all are Muslims and yet they are considered as stars in this country. Why? Because, every one has been given equal rights by the Indian constitution. Even industry salwarts such as billionoire Azim Premzi who heads the IT giant Wipro, is a Muslim. To top it all, the President of this country Abdul Kalam, is a Muslim. Why is this? Why even after being a Muslim, why are we given equal opportunity? This is the beauty of this country. It does not matter what religion you are, you have right of expression, you have right to travel anywhere, you have the right to be yourself - a complete freedom in the largest democracy of the world. Every society has its problems. India has its own share of problems. Even the US has problems such as whites vs blacks, Mexicans vs Americans. Does that mean that the US will give a separate country for the blacks or to the Mexicans (Hispanics) in the US, just because their culture and language are simliar to that of South America???? Pakistanis argue that majority of the people in Kashmir are Muslims, so Kashmir must be a part of Pakistan. Well, get your facts right. India has the largest number of Muslims only after Indonesia. So, if you want to argue on that issue, then, Kashmir should be a part of India. And, what does Pakistan plan to give the Kashmiris? An extremist government that is the mother of all the terrorism around the world? At least in India, they can breathe free. In Pakistan, they will be suffocated to death. Remember, what Pak did to Bangladesh (formerly East Pakistan)? Due to all the suffocation, Bangladesh had to fight for its independence from Pak. I as a Muslim, feel ashamed of this extremist nation. Because of them, every non-Muslim suspects our community as terrorists or Jihadis. We are looked upon suspicion. Why are they doing this to us? This is the 21st century and why are they creating an image that Islam is intolerant towards other??? We don't want to be called as barbarians. Islam is a very peaceful religion. Even the Prophet has said that killing another human is a crime against humanity. I feel pained by the killings of innocents on the name of Islam. If only, in India and in the world, we had an able leader for our community who would let know our feelings to the world as well as fellow Indians. We, Muslims of India, love our fellow Indian brothers and sisters. We don't have any hatred towards Hindus, Christians or any other religion. As in any community, we are currently ill represented by our leaders who are spreading hatred for their own benefit. I sincerely pray that we all leave peacefully practicing our individual faiths. This is the only country in the world, where though the majority is Hindu, the President is a Muslim, the Prime Minister is a Sikh and the strongest political person is a Christian. To conclude ... ' dil diya hai, jaan bhi denge, yeh watan tere liye ' Jai Hind !!! --- Abdul Raheem
Posted by abdul_r805 on Tue, Jun 6, 2006 12:13 AM ET
4
Dear all, please read this editorial published in The Dawn, a Pakistani national newspaper that admits the Pakistani government's support to Jihadis (terrorists) and its implications ... http://www.dawn.com/weekly/mazdak/20030419.htm
Posted by ab_cute7 on Tue, Jun 6, 2006 12:25 AM ET
5
I think Kevin's articles are farily balanced. But being brought up in America, he can not understand somethings and he omits/exagerrats other things to get a nice journalistic story. Looking from an Indian point of view, let me tell you that Rs 250 per day (or $5) is not a bad sum of money at all -especially for a small family. A ordinary doctor's visit (without any insurance) will cost you less than a dollar!! Why, you can even get a chuffer for your car (8 hours a day) for around $2.50 per day. These are the prices in big cities. In smaller cities/villages the prices are even lower. So even though the family potrayed is little poor....especially considering the large size....it is not in that things are totally unaffordable. and they are living a miserbale life. They can afford a doctor, which most poor Americans can't If you consider purchasing power parity a dollar roughly translates to Rs.4-Rs.5 and not Rs.50 as Kevin blindly quotes using the excange rate. So the family earns at least $50-$60 per day. Not good. But not miserable either.
Posted by rchanderetc on Tue, Jun 6, 2006 2:21 AM ET
6
I wonder if it is even worth responding to abdul_r805's ramblings. But this is a common theme you see repeated with all news coverage. People immediately take offense if reports are deemed unfavourable to their own selfish egos. But abdul_r805's ramblings are a good example of how most people in the Indian sub-continent are take most decisons emotionally and without any rational understanding of a fellow human beings suffererings. What does this report have to do with your brother fighting in Kargil, Abdul Raheem? Living on a boat in this manner is sad and unfortunately not an isolated case of poverty in the Indian sub-continent. Peace. Abdul Aziz
Posted by aziz_unreal79 on Tue, Jun 6, 2006 4:24 AM ET
7
I like boats. I like kashmir. I like india. Too bad the family has to live on a boat. But it gives me a quaint story about boat people to read, so I guess I like that sort of thing. If we could all live together on boats, we would have world peace. We could fish and swim together, grow gills on our faces, etc. Happy fishing
Posted by entimoru on Tue, Jun 6, 2006 5:13 AM ET
8
I always read Kevin stories as they opens a awful lot of mind windows. Though I think his reports from Asia are lacking the same depth as the reports from Africa. His upbringing is different and so is his perspectives in many ways. But the point is if we want to do something positive we can as our president says in all his books and we in India have a major edge despite of the difficulties. Kevins goals are different and he is achieving under the constrainshe works in. His goals are to let as many people know of the sufferings of this world of which most Americans are not aware of.
Posted by arnabsharma on Tue, Jun 6, 2006 5:58 AM ET
9
Emperor Jehangir is generally regarded by serious historians as a man who was used to indulging in worldly pleasures at the cost of his vast empire; in fact, there are many who feel that had it not been for his son, Aurangzeb’s stentorian and austere lifestyle, the Mughal Empire would have become the stuff of history much before Bahadur Shah gave himself up to poetry and lost the right to rule. Historians are usually not kind people; they record events only by the yardstick of expanding geographical lines and fallen dominions. Jehangir, fortunately for some of us who see beauty even in refusals, had an eye and soul for romance. It was he who, through the drunken eyes of an impromptu empire-builder, set foot on Kashmir and described what for his infantry was yet another long haul through unfriendly snow and tough terrains. Looking out, with empire-building the last thing in his thoughts, he is said to have muttered in joyous ecstasy, “If ever there was a paradise on earth, here it is.’’ Since the, the pleasures of Kashmir have always been equated with the vicarious feeling of being in a state of blissful heaven. Not that the valley is without its problems, with Indian regime holding it under siege, and suppressing its peace loving habitants and holding them like eagles in cage, destroying its infrastructure and advocating state terrorism. Unfortunately all tales of romances have their own webs of obstacles and problems. It has been only for the last two three years that the tourist inflow has “normalised” with the placement of Puppet Government trying to bring “results” to its the Central Govt. and lending a helping hand to New Delhi with an appetite for paradise. The first movements inside Srinagar thus betray a sense of urgency; to get over with it before the obstacles surface. But rushing through with Srinagar and the Dal Lake would be to literally miss the woods for the trees. You need time to romance the Lake as it meanders through the summer capital of the state. The houseboat on the Lake is ubiquitous; for those of us for whom houses have only meant structures on land, this residence on water is a novelty hard to describe. The houseboat could be explored as a symbol of ethnic living in Kahmir. Most people in Srinagar live on these ``gondolas of the east’’; while those for tourists have their luxurious paraphernalia, the locals make do with sloping roofs and the attachments that make for the necessities of routine life. Tourist shopping, as distinct from local trading, is done on shikaras, there are those popular instruments for long-distance conversations on these same sails. Everything seems to be happening in Kashmir right now for history to record. With perhaps a seriousness which does not go only with the dull alignments of political requirements. Tourism is back to being serious business in Kashmir; if there has been a wink or two in between, then those have been the aberrations of warped priorities. The smile that the new tourist brings back from Kashmir nowadays is the symbol of all that romance has always stood for. The forked beauty of the valley beckons. It’s romancing the ripple again. Not only Kashmiri women, but also Boat people are the most affected category of Kashmiries due to the unjustified Indian Army Presence in this region. The increased occurrence of grenade blasts in Srinagar and other parts of the state is a highly condomnable. Whether, innocent locals are targeted or tourists from outside the state or the country, the killings of civilians is highly shocking and needs to be condemned with the contempt it deserves. There can be no talk of peace and justice in the existing scenario where rampant killings of innocent tourists, at the hands of BJP who wants to come to Power at any cost, affects boat peoples daily surviving. Rhetoric alone is not enough. Consistency and adequate steps are more important. Strangely, the killings are mired in mystery with Army forces pinning blame on certain outfits and the militant outfits promptly condemning such attacks. While it is important to investigate who is behind these attacks, it is equally important to realise that sixteen years of heavy Military presence have created several vested interests at various levels, all of whom want to keep the pot boiling for their own petty gains. The Special Operations Group, which is notorious for picking up young men for questioning and then demanding money for their release, is being assimilated into the Police. "Even today they continue to pick up people and demand a couple of 0.1 million indian currency for their release. Innocent Civilians branded militants are released, for a ransom of Rs 0.6 to 0.7 million”. It is thus important for people, including those at the decision-making level, who have a vested interest in peace to become more and more pro-active. Since statements about a non-existent normalcy cause more provocation. Indian government must realise that there can be no talks of imposing solutions with a handful of people who are distanced from the common masses and Indian Rulers must realise that killings of innocents serves nobody's purpose - neither the agenda of bringing normalcy, nor it can demoralise the cause of Kashmiri’s, and cannot be buried on foundations of unjust and unprincipled killings. The killings re-emphasise the need to foster demilitarisation Plan, which seems to have been rejected by all the people at the decision making level in New Delhi. The bottom line is that the presence of Indian forces has to be vacated and the culture of militarising civilian space must come to end. The daily killings of innocents by Army troops cannot be cordoned. Demilitarisation is must for bringing justice and peace in this beautiful and brutalised region, occupied by India.
Posted by scientificsouls on Tue, Jun 6, 2006 6:38 AM ET
10
scienticficsouls, your eloquence is immediate and heart-rendering. i hope you can compile all of your posts in one place for people to understand the depth of injustice visited upon Kashmir. I am a kashmiri and it breaks my heart to see such deprivation, dispossession and cruelty visited upon our people, people who were backed up against the wall, forced to fight for their dignity and freedom. Indian chauvinism and cruelty is the same time astounding, laughable and beneath contempt. Only a people who grovelled under the heels of a handful of foreigners for so long can have their psyche so distorted and tortured. A people trying to wipe out their overwhelming shame by trting to snuff out the most helpless. God has a special place in hell for such kind of animals.
Posted by asifkh on Tue, Jun 6, 2006 7:02 AM ET

ALSO ON YAHOO!

One Man. One Year. A World of Conflict.

Kevin's Flickr Photo Journal

Other Trip Posts

Add to My Yahoo!/RSS

  • Add Hot Zone headlines to My Yahoo!

    Add to My Yahoo! xml
» All News RSS Feeds
share this page
Alerts BellAdd an Alert - Receive the latest Hot Zone dispatches by email, instant message or mobile phone.

Learn More


» Web Search: Kashmir

HOW TO HELP

in memoriam

The Kevin Sites in the Hot Zone team dedicates this site to Marla Ruzicka, a fearless voice of compassion, who was killed in Iraq on April 16, 2005, while trying to lessen the suffering of others. For more information, see Civic Worldwide.