HOME

 

MYANMAR ARCHIVE: June 27 - July 10 2006

The Longest War

The Karen National Liberation Army has waged the longest fight for independence in the world. Now, 58 years later, they may be no closer to their goal than when they started.

By Kevin Sites, Wed Jun 28, 4:54 PM ET

KAREN STATE, Myanmar - When you are meeting a rebel army, I have learned, there is always a dirt road to travel. This occasion, it seems, is no different.

Off a well-paved highway running north from Mae Sot, Thailand, my driver, Nibo, makes a sudden left, wheeling the silver Toyota pickup onto a winding dirt pathway leading through a seemingly endless expanse of cornfields.

It is, as usual during monsoon season, dreary gray, on the cusp of another afternoon downpour. Rows of green stalks rustle in the wind, lulling me into an almost hypnotic calm. But then, after only a few minutes, the ride is over.

Video

Exploring the KNLA encampment
» View

Nibo is out of the vehicle and leading me through the fields. We are mice in a maze of green. When we emerge on the other side, we are on the southeastern bank of the Moei River, which separates Thailand from what was once called Burma, renamed Myanmar in 1989 by the military junta that rules the country.

A long wooden dugout powered by a small outboard motor is waiting for us. We climb aboard and are transported only about 100 yards upriver before we tie up on the other side. Burma.

On the ledge above us I see the silhouette of two men in uniform. As I get closer I can see that one is in his early 20s and the other no younger than his late 50s. The older man extends his hand and introduces himself as Sanplo. He is wearing green fatigues and a maroon beret. He smiles broadly, revealing the few teeth he has left, badly stained brown from chewing betel nut.

"Please excuse me," he says, "my English is not so good."

He leads us over the ridge to an encampment of thatch buildings, including a large meeting place guarded by two young fighters, one armed with the most ubiquitous assault rifle in the world, the Russian-designed AK-47. The other holds an American-made M-16.

Inside, a handful of older men, mostly dressed like Sanplo, await my arrival. They are, I'm told, the leadership of Battalion 101 of the 7th Brigade of the Karen National Liberation Army (KNLA).

The KNLA and its coordinating political arm, the Karen National Union (KNU), have waged a war of liberation against the Burmese military government since shortly after Burma's independence from Britain in 1948. It is a rebellion against ethnic oppression, according to the Karen people, which they have suffered at the hands of the military regime.

At 58 years and counting, the Karen conflict, one of several ethnic conflicts in Burma, is the oldest civil war in the world. From this exposure, it appears the men who are leading it have not missed much of that struggle.

The first commander is introduced to me as Colonel Pawdoh, 51, the youngest of the bunch. He wears a beret, striped polo shirt, black cargo pants and zip up combat boots. His mouth full of betel nut, he says he has been with the KNLA since he was 20 years old.

The second command is a 63-year-old, named Major Thasu, who claims he has fought with the KNLA for 44 years. The battalion's adjutant is a bespectacled and kindly-looking 65-year-old named Captain Raylo, a veteran of 42 years.

On the wall behind a lectern is a painting of Saw Ba U Gyi, the founder and first chairman of the Karen National Union (KNU). Flanking the painting on either side are the KNU's four principles, written in English on the left and in curvy Karen script on the right.

Photos

Fighting a regime » View

While we speak, I write them in my notebook:

1) For us, surrender is out of the question.
2) We shall retain our arms.
3) The recognition of the Karen State must be complete.
4) We shall decide our own political destiny.

They seem, as I look at them, to be ready-made demands, both reaffirmation of the struggle's purpose (probably necessary in one this protracted) as well as clear signposts of deal-breaking points in any negotiations with the Burmese government, known by its latest Big Brother-esque acronym, the SPDC, or State Peace and Development Council.

And at this point in its existence, both the political wing, the KNU, and the military arm, the KNLA, need all the reaffirmation they can muster. They are plagued by division, aging leadership and shortages of manpower and materials.

"At the present," says Pawdoh, "we have no operations going on. We are working on peaceful negotiations."

And in fact there is a kind of "gentlemen's agreement," as Pawdoh calls it, between the KNLA and the Burmese military — the result of a meeting with the military junta in Yangon two years ago.

But it seems to be, at best, a loose agreement. Regular violence is reported, with a flood of Karen and other Burmese refugees crossing the border into Thailand any time there is fresh fighting between the KNLA and government troops.

"The Burmese military constantly violates the cease-fire," says Mahn Sha, the general secretary of the Karen National Union, from a location in Mae Sot on the Thai side of the border. "If they don't stop their military offensive against the Karen people, we will be forced to defend ourselves."

But the threat seems to lack teeth. Quietly, many in the Karen leadership concede that the lengthy struggle has sapped the will of many of the Karen people to continue the fight.

One of the biggest setbacks to the KNU/KNLA's struggle came in 1995, when a breakaway faction called the Democratic Karen Buddhist Army (DKBA) split with the KNLA over disagreements with what they say was a bias in favor of Christians within the KNLA.

That group began working with the Burmese Army. Their insider knowledge, many Karen people believe, allowed the Burmese military to overrun the KNU headquarters at Manerplaw inside Burma in 1995, forcing the leadership and thousands of refugees to flee to the borderlands and across the Thai border.

It was a strategic defeat that both the KNU and KNLA have never fully recovered from.

Another major obstacle for the KNLA, as far as providing a military backbone to the KNU's political pressure, is the lack of military supplies to equip their army.

Major Thasu says the KNLA gets a lot of verbal support from the international community but few weapons, while the Burmese government is supplied with arms from China and India — and by some reports it is also getting new weapons from Russia.

The KNLA, says Thasu, must rely on small arms they can capture from the SPDC or weapons they can buy with money funneled to them through work operations like logging and farming by the Karen people.

Waiting inside the KNLA camp

But the weapons available to purchase, including Vietnam-era M-16s, are often aging as fast as the KNLA leadership.

Both the Burmese military and the KNLA have been accused of profiting from the drug trade (Burma is the second-largest opium producer in the world, behind

Afghanistan) and using those funds to purchase weapons.

Thasu denies the charges that either the KNLA leadership or soldiers are involved with drugs.

"It's illegal," he says. "We take action against anyone who deals with drugs."

The KNLA does admit, however, to experimenting with the use of child soldiers in the mid-1980s, when they developed what they called "the Boy's Company," an entire unit of 14-, 15- and 16-year-old boys orphaned or made homeless through fighting with government troops.

Mahn Sha, the KNU's general secretary, says that international law and pressure made them disband the Boy's Company two years after it started.

However, in an impromptu visit to another KNLA Battalion inside Burma, I came across a boy easily between 12 and 14, shouldering an M-16.

I had clearly surprised him and the other adult soldier he was with. The boy nearly ran into the bush, while I captured just a few seconds of videotape of him.

Mahn Sha says this was an anomaly — that the boy probably just works in the 22nd Battalion's office and does not go to the front lines — even though he was carrying a weapon. Regardless, he said he would look into the incident.

Twenty-year-old Ehphno Roe of the 101st Battalion is old enough to go the front lines, though. He plans to start his day-and-a-half walk there tomorrow morning.

A contrasting youthful face to the KNLA elders I've just met, he says he's been with the rebel force for two years, and that his father is also a fighter.

"I'm not afraid to go to the front," he says with calm but underlying bravado. "The SPDC is oppressing our people. This is what we have to do."

But after 58 years, the lingering question is how much longer the KNLA will have to fight before the Karen people achieve the independence, or at least autonomy, they crave, or whether they will have to submit completely to the rule of the Burmese military government.

http://hotzone.yahoo.com/b/hotzone/blogs6770

RECOMMEND THIS STORY

Recommend It:

Average (Not Rated)

0.0 stars
Hot Zone Watch List
  • Algeria
  • Angola
  • Burundi
  • Chad
  • Ivory Coast
  • Korean Peninsula
  • Liberia
  • Nigeria
  • Peru
  • The Philippines
  • Thailand
  • Uzbekistan
  • Zimbabwe

Comments

Join the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

1
In my opinion, KNU is as bad as SPDC. I bet you anything that they are still using child solders and selling opium to fund their fight and committing all kinds of atrocities. The civil war is the stupidest kind of war you can fight because innocent people get caught up in it just because a handful of idiots want their own "independence." All the ethnic groups in Burma fought together for independence from British. And as soon as we got it, they wanted to break away? And how exactly did Burmese people "oppress" Karen people? As far as I know, we get along just fine. It's the junta they should be hating, not Burmese people. I'm 1/4 Karen and have friends and relatives in Karen state who hate SPDC pigs, but no desire whatsover to break away from the mainland. That's the last thing on their mind. Like I said, it's not fair to make other people suffer because some morons want to play king. And that "Saw Ba U Gyi" guy, their so-called leader is a mormon who has a bunch of wives and who most likely fought the war because he didn't want to live under a Buddhist country and wanted his own Christian kingdom. Well, tough! I hate KNU and all other rebel grops as much as I hate SPDC. None of them is good for the country. We have hundreds of ethnic groups in Burma and we can't let them break away just because they want to. Otherwise, the whole country would be broken pieces by pieces. Take Karen state for example, there are just so much culture and history and iconic places like "Thar-Ma-Nya" mountain and pagados in "Pha-An" that if we lose it, we would lose a part of our identity. Whether every Karen people like it or not, Karen state is a part of Burma, a part of our soul. It belongs to Burma just like the rest of 13 states do. Without any of them, we wouldn't be whole. I understand they don't like being under the rule of the junta, no one does. But that doesn't give them the right to try to form their own country. If they want to fight, they should fight together with NLD and try to liberate the whole Burma. No matter how much they hate the junta, breaking up the country is just not the answer.
Posted by pann_padout on Wed, Jun 28, 2006 6:34 PM ET
2
The Karen people are not fighting for independence but rather autonomy. They want to be part of a Federal system like Germany and the U.S. that allows for a degree of local self-rule. Unfortunately, the rest of the people in Myanmar have meekly given in to the military government, to the point that they allowed that government to rename the country and make it an international pariah state. There should be an organized resistance in Rangoon but instead there is compliance. The problem with the rest of Myanmar is that they want the Karens to make all the sacrifices in the fight against the SPDC and they want to reap the benefits.
Posted by littlearminius on Wed, Jun 28, 2006 9:36 PM ET
3
Dear Pann Padout: Do other Burmese share your bigoted attitude toward non-Burmese groups? If they do, it's no wonder the Karen believe that they need their own state. Do you *really* hate the KNU and other rebel groups as much as you hatethe SPDC? If you do, then you are not paying attention. Educate yourself about the problems of the Karen and other ethnic groups, show some respect for their very legitimate concerns, and perhaps there will be room for a united effort against the junta. But if all you want to do is whine (see above), please keep your ignorance to yourself.
Posted by s_paskey on Wed, Jun 28, 2006 9:50 PM ET
4
As always "Kevin Sites" writes a story based on the canned formula of sensationalism. Much of it is claptrap. He may not even go to many of these places. And surely some people will post comments saying "Dear Kevin" as if "Kevin" is going to read this stuff. If you want to find out the background of anything, you are going to have make the effort of going to the library and so on. Yahoo News in general is full of mistakes.
Posted by meiguoren100 on Wed, Jun 28, 2006 10:22 PM ET
5
We Filipinos also have or own decades long separatists problems and we may be the country with the longest running communist insurgency too - I'm not so sure. Any way, I think your story failed to include a list of sorts to substantiate the Karen people's claim of ethnic oppression suffered from the Burmees. For the other corner (the rest of Burma I suppose) - where's their list of reasons why the KNU/KNLA should just pack up and get over it? It feels as if waiting to "see" Pann Padout and S_Paskey go at each other throats promises more insight to these questions than your story!
Posted by riceroles on Wed, Jun 28, 2006 11:31 PM ET
6
Just so you know the UNHCR calls these people after 58 years misplaced ? Its that a whopper? Misplaced hows that if you misplace someone and find them they are no longer misplaced. Or is that a budgetary reason?
Posted by dealmake on Thu, Jun 29, 2006 1:31 AM ET
7
War always involve bad examples, especially in situations like this, while I sympathise with the Karen people in their oppression, but a 12-year old soldier? It's evil. What will he be doing when he is 20 or 30? Or should they suddenly achieve their aim. The effects of after wars on children. Let's pray for an end to this war.
Posted by boldjonny on Thu, Jun 29, 2006 2:54 AM ET
8
I have been to Burma and to tell the truth it is the most filthy and dispicable place I have ever been. You see 10 year old kids walking the streets smoking and begging from any one who looks western. It is a pure shame the country could be very beautiful. If the people of burma put half the effort to clean the place up that they do in fighting amongst each other the would be supprised at what they could do. All of the Burmese people need to band together and get rid of the junta. But as long as there is ethnic strife I am afraid there will be no peace and prosperity for Burma
Posted by jimbrock63 on Thu, Jun 29, 2006 7:02 AM ET
9
Subhead has a typo: Should be "...no closer than
Posted by bharma on Thu, Jun 29, 2006 7:23 AM ET
10
Americans can't even keep gw bush out of office but can easily criticize the Burmese people for not cleaning up their country and fighting the oppressors??? get a clue. turn the air cooler down, park your suv, throw away your mobile phone and turn off the tv.
Posted by serum108 on Thu, Jun 29, 2006 7:27 AM ET

ALSO ON YAHOO!

One Man. One Year. A World of Conflict.

Kevin's Flickr Photo Journal

Other Trip Posts

Add to My Yahoo!/RSS

  • Add Hot Zone headlines to My Yahoo!

    Add to My Yahoo! xml
» All News RSS Feeds
share this page
Alerts BellAdd an Alert - Receive the latest Hot Zone dispatches by email, instant message or mobile phone.

Learn More


» Web Search: Myanmar

HOW TO HELP

  • Red Cross in Myanmar - provides for the basic health, water, and sanitation needs of people in selected villages, and works to protect civilians in sensitive areas.
  • Doctors Without Borders: Myanmar - centers projects around those living with malaria, tuberculosis, and sexually transmitted infections including HIV/AIDS.
  • Save the Children: Myanmar - works to provide children with access to quality education, adequate healthcare, and economic security.
  • U.N. Refugee Agency: Myanmar - works to safeguard the rights and well-being of refugees.
  • U.N. Development Programme: Myanmar - focuses activities on areas of poverty reduction, local governance, the environment, and HIV/AIDS in order to boost the well being of the people.
  • Human Rights Watch: Myanmar - bulletins and in-depth reports on the human rights developments in the country.
  • Clear Path International - works with land mine and bomb survivors, their families and their communities on the Thai-Myanmar border, Vietnam and Cambodia.

in memoriam

The Kevin Sites in the Hot Zone team dedicates this site to Marla Ruzicka, a fearless voice of compassion, who was killed in Iraq on April 16, 2005, while trying to lessen the suffering of others. For more information, see Civic Worldwide.