HOME

 

CAMBODIA ARCHIVE: July 10-21, 2006

The Killing Field

Choeung Ek was only one of many killing fields during the Cambodian genocide, but its pagoda full of skulls has become the most poignant symbol of justice delayed.

By Kevin Sites, Wed Jul 12, 1:02 PM ET

Note: Though Cambodia is not an active conflict, Kevin Sites in the Hot Zone believes it is important to examine the country's brutal past under the

Khmer Rouge. In focusing on the lessons learned and the lingering problems, we'll explore how the conflict is reflected in Cambodia today.

PHNOM PENH, Cambodia - The staggering crime of 17,000 murders could not be buried in the orchards of Choeung Ek for long, although the Khmer Rouge did try.

Here in a quiet field 15 kilometers from Phnom Penh, the ground is pitted with 129 mass graves where men, women and children were tossed after most had been killed by bludgeoning with rifle butts, bamboo stakes and logs — to save bullets.

It is difficult to fathom, but some who were there and survived describe babies being tossed in the air and caught on the end of rifle bayonets by sadistic Khmer Rouge executioners.

Video

Tour the killing field » View

But nature, it seems, was a witness to these deeds, not an accomplice. The shallow graves easily exposed the horrors beneath. One year after the fall of the Khmer Rouge, 86 of the graves were eventually dug up and the bodies of 9,000 people exhumed. Most were blindfolded and bound.

Forty-three other graves have been left untouched to this day.

The people that were executed here primarily had been transported from the infamous S-21 prison, a former high school in Phnom Penh that the Khmer Rouge transformed into a gallery of horrors, photographing their captives for documentation, then shackling them together or placing them in stalls like animals. They tortured them horribly to extract confessions, then sent them here, to Choeung Ek, to be executed.

From 1975 to 1979, until they were driven from power by the invading Vietnamese Army, the Khmer Rouge killed an estimated two million people in killing fields like this across Cambodia.

To this day no Khmer Rouge leader has ever seen the inside of a courtroom for these crimes. An international tribunal, long in the making between the Cambodian government and the

United Nations, is just now being formed.

So justice, it seems, painfully slow to be served, must be buttressed for now with symbols of remembrance and respect for the suffering of so many. In that effort, Choeunk Ek, like S-21, has been turned into a memorial to the genocide. It has become the nation's most unforgettable, because of the brutality that was done here.

Mao Thel lost his mother, father and uncle in the Khmer Rouge killings. He says it's possible that his own family is among those that were killed and buried here.

He has worked for years at Choeung Ek, giving tours to the dozens of people who visit here every day: foreign tourists mostly, who, like at Auschwitz or Buchenwald, are quickly confronted by the magnitude of the inhumanities that took place here.

Standing amidst the shallow pits, now covered with grass, is a white pagoda covered by glass on all four sides. It looks to be at least 70 feet high. Inside the pagoda are ten separate wooden platforms, stacked to the top of the structure. Arranged on these platforms, according to sex and age, are the skulls of eight thousand of the 17,000 victims murdered at Choeung Ek.

"This one was killed by electric wire," says Mao, pointing out skulls on the first platform of the pagoda to six young men and women from the United Kingdom. "This one was killed with a bamboo stake through the head and this one by a (garden) hoe."

He raises the last skull to show how it was split completely in half.

Photos

Here, skulls tell the story of horror. » View

The tourists look at the skulls in stunned silence. It is almost impossible to stop looking at them, to first take them in as a whole, a mass of textures. Rows and rows of round, brown, white and gray are an army not of soldiers but of victims — an army of death.

I watch the tourists as they look up and down the platforms, trying to comprehend that there are nine more levels above the one in front of them — the skulls of children and adults, girls and boys, women and men.

On the floor beneath the first platform are some of the clothes the victims were wearing when they were killed. It reminds me of a memorial at a school in Rwanda I visited early in the Hot Zone project. There, victims' clothes were hung across a wire near where their bodies were exhumed following that genocide. The smell of the clothes somehow forced me to see people when looking at the remains — not just bodies, not just victims.

Inside the glass-lined pagoda, the clothes and skulls are open and exposed on their platforms. You can touch them, pick them up and stare closely if you feel the need. There is little separation from the living and dead.

Standing inside the pagoda I begin to understand that whether intended or not, this memorial is not a museum piece. Detaching yourself from this tragedy is not an option.

Here, inside this place, while you look at them, eight thousand skulls look back at you from empty eye sockets, asking you to see more than just their deaths, but their lives.

They once knew laughter and breakfast, the feel of rain and the taste of tea. It was these things they were robbed of and these things they seem to ask you to remember, so that they are more than statistics of a heinous crime, more than skulls on a platform.

In the landscape around the pagoda, other visitors walk between the graves from small shrines filled with bones and teeth to placards, explaining in Khmer and English what took place at the specific locations.

One placard reads that a tree stump is the site where Khmer Rouge soldiers smashed the heads of children. Another, called the "magic tree", reads that microphones were draped over the branches to amplify the moans of agony from those being killed.

It is hard to walk away from Choeung Ek unmoved, to know what has happened here, to see the evidence, to honor the loss — but also to wonder, almost three decades later, if justice lies amongst those bones.

http://hotzone.yahoo.com/b/hotzone/blogs7499

RECOMMEND THIS STORY

Recommend It:

Average (Not Rated)

0.0 stars
Hot Zone Watch List
  • Algeria
  • Angola
  • Burundi
  • Chad
  • Ivory Coast
  • Korean Peninsula
  • Liberia
  • Nigeria
  • Peru
  • The Philippines
  • Thailand
  • Uzbekistan
  • Zimbabwe

Comments

Join the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

1
The phrase, Never Again, after the Holocaust was meant as a warning for future generations of man's depravity. I don't think people have learned much since then. Most people are apathetic to the suffering of other people. They have never witnessed it, never felt it personally so it's just too abstract for them to comprehend. So sad for humanity...
Posted by sid_burracho on Wed, Jul 12, 2006 3:40 PM ET
2
Where will it be next time? Will our children be reading reports of the mass graves in Myanmar, Nepal or Sri Lanka 20 years from now and wondering as we are" Why didn't somebody stop this?". Because of where i was lucky enough to be born, I feel as if I should help somehow, but I also know that alot of these problems need to be addressed by those involved first hand. For now, I will be more careful about which officials I vote for, follow forieghn policy more closely, lend a hand where I can, and pray that I am not judged as harshy as the generation before me. To those who survived atrocities like this, it will never be over. I am humbled before them.
Posted by smalltownwench65 on Wed, Jul 12, 2006 3:52 PM ET
3
The human race tends to wonder how atrocities such as this are "allowed" to occur. Power to make these things happen lies in the apathy of the people watching it take place. So, I only hope people stop watching the small things, i.e. a woman being mugged, just happen... so as to get in the habit of raising voices early so as to avoid events such as the Khmer Rouge.
Posted by stepdancer87 on Wed, Jul 12, 2006 5:55 PM ET
4
I am broken-hearted at the sight of the remains of men, women & children to the point that I want to run and vomit at the thought of it, then I pray and pray that history doesn't repeat itself. I only wish and pray that we, as a world, can weather the seasons of our lives together, as human beings. Barbara A.
Posted by barbarellanes@sbcglobal.net on Wed, Jul 12, 2006 7:01 PM ET
5
The Killing Fields stared humanity in the eye, because it could had done something but did not. Genocide will happen again, as long as we put our political individualistic interests ahead of the whole humanity. Human race will be vanished as long as we fight among ourselves. What have we learned in the last fifty years since the Holocaust? Nothing. Pol Pot will laugh at us from his grave fifty years from now. Because we had learned nothing and remembered nothing. Human race had failed it duty to protect its own.
Posted by slach7470 on Wed, Jul 12, 2006 7:04 PM ET
6
As far as I know, humans are the only species that enjoys killing it's own. It will never change. Perhaps one day man will finally find a reason to annihilate itself. I just hope that the next species that evolves will possess a higher level of commonsense.
Posted by glenota2003 on Wed, Jul 12, 2006 9:26 PM ET
7
Smalltownwrench65 said: Where will it be next time? Will our children be reading reports of the mass graves in Myanmar, Nepal or Sri Lanka 20 years from now and wondering as we are" Why didn't somebody stop this?". I say -- Will our grandchildren or even our children be reading reports of the mass graves in New York, LA, Washington, Phoenix, Seattle or Minneapolis 20 years from now and wonder a we are "Why didn't somebody stop this?" This nation (like so many others) is under attack by terrorists. One dirty bomb, one lethal virus or bacteria, one day of multiple attacks similar to 9-11 could produce a genocide (at least, partial) of the Americans of the United States. I fear that only when war (as we refer to combat fighting) comes to one or more of our shores will our Washington leaders fully recognize that genocide could happen here, unless we, as Americans, show our leaders by our example that we WILL never forget and do whatever we as individuals are able, perhaps even just starting out with helping our fellow Americans (no matter what color, creed, etc.) who are struggling in poverty, and then banding together to help other nations' citizens who also struggle in poverty. Until all people have their basic needs met, there will always be a group who are willing to force another group into conditions in which they would not want to live themselves.
Posted by k213dm on Wed, Jul 12, 2006 10:00 PM ET
8
where will it be? someone asked. does it matter? how about central Africa now? *The human race is apathetic the these things.* i agree with that, but many are apathetic because it is the socialy acceptable thing to do. pwople do not wantto hear about this, so *out of sight out of mind* americans and other 1st world countries, only care about what makes their life better, If it means the mass genocide of other peoples, than so be it. They will just be " Apathetic" and find someone to blame. as long as they get their Diomonds from Africa at a Good Price. Or their gas for their SUV at cheap price. pseudo apathy is an insult. If you actually care about it. look in your self and your own back yard to do something. don:t just sit around and talk about it..
Posted by myownturtle on Wed, Jul 12, 2006 11:41 PM ET
9
one more thing. Genocide has happened in America. "Native Americans" How about the Relocation of Japanese Americans during WWII loosing everything, We As Americans sit ourselves on a high horse and point Fingers when we are no better or no worse than any other country out there. Actually we are worse. because we have the ability to make the world a better place, and we don't. The Idea of America is worth dying for. the imediate actions and practices of America is shameful.
Posted by myownturtle on Wed, Jul 12, 2006 11:55 PM ET
10
I don't think as many people are apathetic as they are overwhelmed by the situations around the world. Look how many people post comments here, and answered the question Bono posted on Yahoo! Answers the other day. I really do think people care, but few of us can make that quantum leap into politics or "saving the world". A large number of people simply get frustrated by the bad news every day, and burdened by the problems in their own lives. I absolutely think we must be aware of what is happening in the world and do what we can to help. However, for most of us it is simply trying to make our own lives and our own communities better, and even that can be a struggle...however, I know that people care and are trying. Perhaps one day, "The energy, the faith, the devotion which we bring to this endeavor will light our country and all who serve it—and the glow from that fire can truly light the world..." (JFK). Thank you Kevin for continuing to bring us stories such as this one. Thank you all for showing me that people still care. Work is being done to try and make this world a better place. Sincerely, -rebelphoenix-
Posted by tenzekbaseball on Thu, Jul 13, 2006 12:07 AM ET

ALSO ON YAHOO!

One Man. One Year. A World of Conflict.

Kevin's Flickr Photo Journal

Other Trip Posts

Add to My Yahoo!/RSS

  • Add Hot Zone headlines to My Yahoo!

    Add to My Yahoo! xml
» All News RSS Feeds
share this page
Alerts BellAdd an Alert - Receive the latest Hot Zone dispatches by email, instant message or mobile phone.

Learn More


  • BBC: Cambodia - includes a map, political history, and a timeline of key events.
  • Wikipedia: Cambodia - includes sections on the country's history, politics, and its demographics.
  • Wikipedia: Khmer Rouge - provides background of the group that ruled Cambodia from 1975 to 1979, and was responsible for the deaths of an estimated 1.7 million people.
  • BBC: Pol Pot - profile of the former leader of the Khmer Rouge.
  • Cambodian Genocide Program - provides documentation of the mass killings in Cambodia under the regime headed by Pol Pot.
» Web Search: Cambodia

HOW TO HELP

in memoriam

The Kevin Sites in the Hot Zone team dedicates this site to Marla Ruzicka, a fearless voice of compassion, who was killed in Iraq on April 16, 2005, while trying to lessen the suffering of others. For more information, see Civic Worldwide.